Welcome to Round 3 of my conceptual* comparison of the three current generation video game consoles. You can go back to round 1 and round 2 if you like.
(*I say “conceptual†because I don’t own any of them. I have played extensively on the 360 and Wii, and very briefly on the PS3. This is not in any way based on direct comparative playtesting.)
Coming into this week, the Playstation 3 is barely in the lead, with the 360 close behind and the Wii trailing. It’s not really the Wii’s fault. Round 2 looked at power, an area where the Wii is outclassed significantly, and Round 1 despite being all about controllers, ended up a wash. Today we look a few things that the Wii just might have an advantage in: price, and backward compatibility.
For those who aren’t aware, backward compatibility is a feature in consoles that allow them to run games programmed for previous console generations. This usually increases a new console’s software library and also allows gamers to play their favorite games from previous generations, at least in an ideal world.
Playstation 3
When it comes to price, the PS3 is like a mugger demanding your wallet. Currently clocking in at $499 for the 60 GB model and $599 for the 80 GB model, it’s easily the most expensive console on the market. Still, I can’t ignore the fact that the components that go into the PS3 still cost more than the final price. As for backward compatibility, the cheaper model actually contains PS2 hardware(!), thus providing a great deal of support for PS2 and PS1 games. The newer models use software emulation for this feature, reducing the percentage of games that can be run. The number currently stands at about 72% in Europe (that’s 1,782 games), and a similar number can probably be expected in the United States.
Xbox 360
The Premium 360 (with a 20 GB hard drive) costs $349 in the US, while the Elite model (with a 120 GB hard drive) costs $449, undercutting the PS3’s price considerably. The less useful Core model, which lacks a hard drive entirely, retails for a mere $279, but is still more expensive than Nintendo’s rather cheap Wii. The cost for components on the 360 is actually less than the the current market price, but I’m unclear on whether Microsoft is really making a profit on consoles after things like marketing are added into the mix. The 360’s backward compatibility isn’t particularly impressive, and is limited to emulating the original Xbox’s software library. 394 Xbox games are currently playable on the 360. Since it took until November of 2006 for the critically acclaimed, award-wining Psychonauts to show up on the 360, It’s pretty clear that Microsoft isn’t too big on the whole backward compatibility deal.
Wii
The Wii is cheap. You get a console, a remote-shaped controller with a “nunchuk†attachment, and a Wii Sports game for just $249. Given that new games generally cost about $50, that’s about 200 bucks for the console itself. GameCube games can be played right out of the box, and Nintendo is releasing older games from its older console via its online Virtual Console (many of these require that a separate Classic Controller be purchased). With the exception of the GameCube games, these are all emulated, and the selection is entirely dependent upon what Nintendo chooses to release.
And this week’s winner is…
Wii!
This round was an interesting battle. The PS3 got knocked down by its high price, but made some of that up with its better backward compatibility. Honestly, I’m most interested in games from the previous generation — the really old ones never seem to play as well as memory would have you believe. But the high amount of compatibility with PS2 games that the PS3 enjoys is certainly a force to be reckoned with. The 360 is hurt a bit by its relative lack of emulation for Xbox games, but its price is better, and that brings it in line with the PS3. The Wii wins mostly because it’s so cheap. You can’t beat the price. Also, while I’m less impressed with the Wii’s backward compatibility, it’s still enough to give it a few points there, too.
This week the Wii scored 5 points, and the PS3 and 360 scored 2 each. That brings the total scores to…
PS3: 7. Wii: 7. Xbox 360: 6.
(a note on scores: each round I pass out up to 10 points total, divided up among the three contestants according to their relative merits. Round 1 was a tie, so I just passed out a single point to each and called it a day.)
Next Week: The Media take over!